Bobina's short life ends tragically

Bobina (outside) broke down right after the finish line of the Senorita
Photo: Benoit, Betfair Hollywood Park

It was not an outcome that anyone could have foreseen.  Bobina, a three-year-old Malibu Moon filly, won the Grade III grassy Senorita at Betfair Hollywood Park today, narrowly prevailing after a brave stretch duel with My Gi Gi , but then, just a second after she crossed the wire, her right front ankle shattered and she fell heavily to the ground.

Her rider, Victor Espinoza, got up in short order, but Bobina never did.  In a display of misplaced zeal, Kevin Krigger, the rider of My Gi Gi, claimed foul against Bobina as she awaited the veterinarian’s needle.  The stewards disallowed the claim, but no one could save Bobina.

When track vets determined that her injuries were catastrophic, they euthanized Bobina as she lay, even as the tote board flashed her number on top and bettors cashed their winning tickets.  The trophy that was meant to honor Bobina’s crowning achievement as a graded stakes winner became her memorial, instead.   It’s small consolation to the people who bred and owned her, Haras Santa Maria de Araras, or to her trainer, A. C. Avila.  They had painstakingly brought Bobina this far, only to lose her, just like that.  Horse racing can be cruel.

Bobina didn’t know how to do anything but win.  Unraced at two, she didn’t make her first start until the last day of March, when she outclassed a field of maiden special weight fillies at Santa Anita, rallying to finish more than two lengths the good of her nearest rival at a mile on the grass, the same conditions she faced in the Senorita today.

She came right back two weeks later and did it again, this time over a sloppy mile in an allowance test that had been taken off the turf.  It was that victory that inspired her connections to take a shot in the Senorita, which seemed to be the perfect spot for this up-and-coming filly who had such a bright future. 

Bobina didn’t disappoint them.  Her courage carried her over the finish line today, even as her ankle failed her.  It’s not known when Bobina sustained the injury that felled her; there was nothing to suggest she’d gone wrong until she suddenly went down. 

Bobina was the fourth foal out of the durable Dynaformer mare, Maliziosa, a multiple stakes winner who won or placed in 12 of her 22 starts, while earning $327,581. In an eerie coincidence, Bobina’s stakes-placed half-brother, Tutti Buona Gente (by Aldebaran), broke down and was vanned off just three days ago in a $10,000 claiming race at Churchill Downs.  It’s not known whether, unlike Bobina, he has survived.

Comma to the Top looks like he could be a good one

Benoit Photo/Hollywood Park

Though the start of Saturday's Cash Call Futurity--Hollywood Park's last Grade I race of the year--was held up for 30 minutes while favored Comma to the Top had a shoe replaced, the two-year-old gelding came out running as if nothing was amiss.  And when Corey Nakatani pushed the button, he effortlessly accelerated in the stretch of the mile and a sixteenth contest and beat everyone else to the wire, holding back even the relentless closing charge of the talented J. P.'s Gusto.  He won like a good horse does, and now his sights are on next spring's Run for the Roses.

Indeed, Comma to the Top's victory in the Cash Call Futurity was only the latest in what is now a five-race winning skein.  He's now won half of his 10 starts, including the Grade III Generous Stakes on the Hollywood turf, and earned $551,600.  Not a bad return on the $22,000 price he brought at auction earlier this year.

Comma to the Top is by far the most successful performer for his modestly priced sire, Bwana Charlie, who stands for $2500 in Ocala.  The bay gelding is a member of Bwana Charlie's second crop, and is the first graded stakes winner for this son of the tried and true Indian Charlie, who rocketed to prominence again this year because of the eye-catching exploits of his Uncle Mo, the all-but-crowned Two-Year-Old Champion Colt of 2010.  His talented daughter, Indian Blessing, was Champion Two-Year-Old Filly in 2007.

A cursory glance at Comma to the Top's pedigree wouldn't have pegged him as one who would become one of the best of his generation, and he was largely dismissed by the commercial marketplace, fetching a bid of onloy $5000 from astute pinhooker Clyde Rice, who plucked him out of the OBS October yearling sale.  Rice's Indian Prairie Ranch subsequently resold him for $22,000 to trainer Peter Miller at this year's OBS April Two-Year-Old-in-Training Sale.  Miller ran Comma to the Top in two maiden claimers; he won his first race for a $50,000 tag at Del Mar in July.

Comma to the Top is out of the Stormy Atlantic mare, Maggies Storm, who is a half-sister to the hard-knocking Yes He's a Pistol, a stakes-winning won of Yes It's True who has so far won 15 races in 71 starts and compiled earnings of $336,868.  It's a family that seems to produce runners who are genuine and sound, and perhaps just a notch below the highest calibre.

So what's the explanation for Comma to the Top's rise to the ranks of elite runners?  It might be in the fact that he's got no less than four distant crosses of the great Almahmoud, who John P. Sparkman has called, "the single most influential broodmare of the 20th century's second half."  And rightfully so.  Almahmoud is the ancestress of Bwana Charlie's maternal grandsire, the influential Halo (out of Cosmah), as well as of Northern Dancer (out of Natalma), who appears in Comma to the Top's pedigree both through Stormy Atlantic and in Bwana Charlie's fourth and fifth generation.

This pattern of inbreeding to Almahmoud by nicking the Northern Dancer and Halo lines has been a tried and true method of producing high-class athletes.  Among its most famous examples is two-time Champion Filly and Mare, Ashado (by Halo's son, Saint Ballado, out of Goulash, by Northern Dancer's son, Mari's Book).  And this year, we saw a similar pedigree pattern repeated in Eskendereya (Giant's Causeway -- Aldebaran Light, by Seattle Slew), whose brilliance was cut short before it really had a chance to shine. 

Whether Comma to the Top will be in the same league remains to be seen, but it's clear that he's moving in the right direction.